Translate

Saturday, 11 October 2014

Emasculated male MPs only very slightly more likely to defy three-line whip than female MPs

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2770534/Parliament-debates-British-military-action-Iraq.html

MALE MPs FOR AIRSTRIKES
  1. Adams, Nigel
  2. Afriyie, Adam
  3. Ainsworth, rh Mr Bob
  4. Aldous, Peter
  5. Alexander, rh Danny
  6. Alexander, rh Mr Douglas
  7. Amess, Mr David
  8. Anderson, Mr David
  9. Andrew, Stuart
  10. Arbuthnot, rh Mr James
  11. Ashworth, Jonathan
  12. Austin, Ian
  13. Bailey, Mr Adrian
  14. Bain, Mr William
  15. Baldry, rh Sir Tony
  16. Balls, rh Ed
  17. Banks, Gordon
  18. Barclay, Stephen
  19. Barker, rh Gregory
  20. Barron, rh Kevin
  21. Bayley, Hugh
  22. Bebb, Guto
  23. Beith, rh Sir Alan
  24. Bellingham, Mr Henry
  25. Benn, rh Hilary
  26. Benyon, Richard
  27. Beresford, Sir Paul
  28. Berry, Jake
  29. Betts, Mr Clive
  30. Bingham, Andrew
  31. Binley, Mr Brian
  32. Blackman, Bob
  33. Blenkinsop, Tom
  34. Blomfield, Paul
  35. Blunkett, rh Mr David
  36. Boles, Nick
  37. Bone, Mr Peter
  38. Brady, Mr Graham
  39. Brake, rh Tom
  40. Brazier, Mr Julian
  41. Brennan, Kevin
  42. Bridgen, Andrew
  43. Brine, Steve
  44. Brokenshire, James
  45. Brown, rh Mr Nicholas
  46. Brown, Mr Russell
  47. Browne, Mr Jeremy
  48. Bruce, rh Sir Malcolm
  49. Buckland, Mr Robert
  50. Burden, Richard
  51. Burley, Mr Aidan
  52. Burnham, rh Andy
  53. Burns, Conor
  54. Burrowes, Mr David
  55. Burstow, rh Paul
  56. Burt, rh Alistair
  57. Byles, Dan
  58. Byrne, rh Mr Liam
  59. Cable, rh Vince
  60. Cairns, Alun
  61. Cameron, rh Mr David
  62. Campbell, rh Mr Alan
  63. Campbell, Mr Gregory
  64. Campbell, rh Sir Menzies
  65. Carmichael, rh Mr Alistair
  66. Carmichael, Neil
  67. Cash, Sir William
  68. Chishti, Rehman
  69. Chope, Mr Christopher
  70. Clappison, Mr James
  71. Clark, rh Greg
  72. Clarke, rh Mr Kenneth
  73. Clarke, rh Mr Tom
  74. Clegg, rh Mr Nick
  75. Clifton-Brown, Geoffrey
  76. Coaker, Vernon
  77. Collins, Damian
  78. Colvile, Oliver
  79. Cox, Mr Geoffrey
  80. Crabb, rh Stephen
  81. Crausby, Mr David
  82. Crockart, Mike
  83. Cruddas, Jon
  84. Cryer, John
  85. Cunningham, Alex
  86. Cunningham, Mr Jim
  87. Cunningham, Sir Tony
  88. Danczuk, Simon
  89. Darling, rh Mr Alistair
  90. Davey, rh Mr Edward
  91. David, Wayne
  92. Davies, David T. C.
  93. Davies, Geraint
  94. Davies, Glyn
  95. de Bois, Nick
  96. Denham, rh Mr John
  97. Djanogly, Mr Jonathan
  98. Dobson, rh Frank
  99. Docherty, Thomas
  100. Dodds, rh Mr Nigel
  101. Donaldson, rh Mr Jeffrey M.
  102. Doughty, Stephen
  103. Dowd, Jim
  104. Drax, Richard
  105. Dromey, Jack
  106. Duddridge, James
  107. Dugher, Michael
  108. Duncan, rh Sir Alan
  109. Duncan Smith, rh Mr Iain
  110. Dunne, Mr Philip
  111. Efford, Clive
  112. Ellis, Michael
  113. Ellwood, Mr Tobias
  114. Elphicke, Charlie
  115. Esterson, Bill
  116. Eustice, George
  117. Evans, Chris
  118. Evans, Graham
  119. Evans, Jonathan
  120. Evans, Mr Nigel
  121. Evennett, Mr David
  122. Fallon, rh Michael
  123. Farrelly, Paul
  124. Farron, Tim
  125. Field, rh Mr Frank
  126. Field, Mark
  127. Flello, Robert
  128. Foster, rh Mr Don
  129. Fox, rh Dr Liam
  130. Francis, Dr Hywel
  131. Francois, rh Mr Mark
  132. Freeman, George
  133. Freer, Mike
  134. Fuller, Richard
  135. Gapes, Mike
  136. Gardiner, Barry
  137. Garnier, Sir Edward
  138. Garnier, Mark
  139. Gauke, Mr David
  140. George, Andrew
  141. Gibb, Mr Nick
  142. Gilbert, Stephen
  143. Glen, John
  144. Goldsmith, Zac
  145. Goodwill, Mr Robert
  146. Gove, rh Michael
  147. Graham, Richard
  148. Gray, Mr James
  149. Grayling, rh Chris
  150. Greatrex, Tom
  151. Green, rh Damian
  152. Grieve, rh Mr Dominic
  153. Griffiths, Andrew
  154. Gummer, Ben
  155. Gwynne, Andrew
  156. Gyimah, Mr Sam
  157. Hague, rh Mr William
  158. Hain, rh Mr Peter
  159. Halfon, Robert
  160. Hames, Duncan
  161. Hamilton, Fabian
  162. Hammond, rh Mr Philip
  163. Hammond, Stephen
  164. Hancock, rh Matthew
  165. Hancock, Mr Mike
  166. Hands, rh Greg
  167. Harper, Mr Mark
  168. Harrington, Richard
  169. Harris, Mr Tom
  170. Harvey, Sir Nick
  171. Haselhurst, rh Sir Alan
  172. Havard, Mr Dai
  173. Hayes, rh Mr John
  174. Heald, Sir Oliver
  175. Healey, rh John
  176. Heaton-Harris, Chris
  177. Hemming, John
  178. Hendrick, Mark
  179. Hendry, Charles
  180. Herbert, rh Nick
  181. Heyes, David
  182. Hinds, Damian
  183. Hoban, Mr Mark
  184. Hollingbery, George
  185. Hollobone, Mr Philip
  186. Hood, Mr Jim
  187. Hopkins, Kris
  188. Horwood, Martin
  189. Howarth, rh Mr George
  190. Howarth, Sir Gerald
  191. Howell, John
  192. Hughes, rh Simon
  193. Hunt, rh Mr Jeremy
  194. Hunt, Tristram
  195. Hurd, Mr Nick
  196. Irranca-Davies, Huw
  197. Jackson, Mr Stewart
  198. Jarvis, Dan
  199. Javid, rh Sajid
  200. Jenkin, Mr Bernard
  201. Jenrick, Robert
  202. Johnson, Gareth
  203. Johnson, Joseph
  204. Jones, Andrew
  205. Jones, rh Mr David
  206. Jones, Graham
  207. Jones, Mr Kevan
  208. Jones, Mr Marcus
  209. Joyce, Eric
  210. Kane, Mike
  211. Kawczynski, Daniel
  212. Kelly, Chris
  213. Khan, rh Sadiq
  214. Kirby, Simon
  215. Knight, rh Sir Greg
  216. Kwarteng, Kwasi
  217. Lamb, rh Norman
  218. Lammy, rh Mr David
  219. Lancaster, Mark
  220. Lansley, rh Mr Andrew
  221. Laws, rh Mr David
  222. Lee, Dr Phillip
  223. Lefroy, Jeremy
  224. Leigh, Sir Edward
  225. Leslie, Chris
  226. Letwin, rh Mr Oliver
  227. Lewis, Brandon
  228. Lewis, Mr Ivan
  229. Lewis, Dr Julian
  230. Lidington, rh Mr David
  231. Lilley, rh Mr Peter
  232. Lloyd, Stephen
  233. Lopresti, Jack
  234. Lord, Jonathan
  235. Loughton, Tim
  236. Love, Mr Andrew
  237. Lucas, Ian
  238. Luff, Sir Peter
  239. Mahmood, Mr Khalid
  240. Mann, John
  241. Marsden, Mr Gordon
  242. Maude, rh Mr Francis
  243. Maynard, Paul
  244. McCabe, Steve
  245. McCann, Mr Michael
  246. McCartney, Jason
  247. McCartney, Karl
  248. McCrea, Dr William
  249. McDonald, Andy
  250. McFadden, rh Mr Pat
  251. McGovern, Jim
  252. McLoughlin, rh Mr Patrick
  253. Meacher, rh Mr Michael
  254. Meale, Sir Alan
  255. Mearns, Ian
  256. Menzies, Mark
  257. Metcalfe, Stephen
  258. Miliband, rh Edward
  259. Miller, Andrew
  260. Mitchell, rh Mr Andrew
  261. Moore, rh Michael
  262. Morris, David
  263. Morris, James
  264. Mosley, Stephen
  265. Mowat, David
  266. Mulholland, Greg
  267. Mundell, rh David
  268. Murphy, rh Mr Jim
  269. Murphy, rh Paul
  270. Murrison, Dr Andrew
  271. Neill, Robert
  272. Newmark, Mr Brooks
  273. Nuttall, Mr David
  274. O'Brien, rh Mr Stephen
  275. Offord, Dr Matthew
  276. Ollerenshaw, Eric
  277. Opperman, Guy
  278. Osborne, rh Mr George
  279. Ottaway, rh Sir Richard
  280. Owen, Albert
  281. Paice, rh Sir James
  282. Paisley, Ian
  283. Parish, Neil
  284. Paterson, rh Mr Owen
  285. Pawsey, Mark
  286. Penning, rh Mike
  287. Penrose, John
  288. Percy, Andrew
  289. Perkins, Toby
  290. Phillips, Stephen
  291. Pickles, rh Mr Eric
  292. Pincher, Christopher
  293. Poulter, Dr Daniel
  294. Pound, Stephen
  295. Pritchard, Mark
  296. Pugh, John
  297. Raab, Mr Dominic
  298. Randall, rh Sir John
  299. Raynsford, rh Mr Nick
  300. Reed, Mr Jamie
  301. Reed, Mr Steve
  302. Rees-Mogg, Jacob
  303. Reevell, Simon
  304. Reid, Mr Alan
  305. Reynolds, Jonathan
  306. Robathan, rh Mr Andrew
  307. Robertson, rh Sir Hugh
  308. Robertson, John
  309. Robertson, Mr Laurence
  310. Robinson, Mr Geoffrey
  311. Rogerson, Dan
  312. Rosindell, Andrew
  313. Roy, Lindsay
  314. Ruane, Chris
  315. Russell, Sir Bob
  316. Rutley, David
  317. Sanders, Mr Adrian
  318. Sarwar, Anas
  319. Sawford, Andy
  320. Selous, Andrew
  321. Shannon, Jim
  322. Shapps, rh Grant
  323. Sharma, Alok
  324. Sharma, Mr Virendra
  325. Shepherd, Sir Richard
  326. Sheridan, Jim
  327. Shuker, Gavin
  328. Simmonds, Mark
  329. Simpson, David
  330. Simpson, Mr Keith
  331. Skidmore, Chris
  332. Slaughter, Mr Andy
  333. Smith, Henry
  334. Smith, Julian
  335. Smith, Nick
  336. Smith, Owen
  337. Smith, Sir Robert
  338. Soames, rh Sir Nicholas
  339. Spellar, rh Mr John
  340. Spencer, Mr Mark
  341. Stanley, rh Sir John
  342. Stephenson, Andrew
  343. Stevenson, John
  344. Stewart, Bob
  345. Stewart, Iain
  346. Stewart, Rory
  347. Streeter, Mr Gary
  348. Stride, Mel
  349. Stuart, Mr Graham
  350. Stunell, rh Sir Andrew
  351. Sturdy, Julian
  352. Sutcliffe, Mr Gerry
  353. Swales, Ian
  354. Swayne, rh Mr Desmond
  355. Swire, rh Mr Hugo
  356. Syms, Mr Robert
  357. Tami, Mark
  358. Thomas, Mr Gareth
  359. Thornton, Mike
  360. Timms, rh Stephen
  361. Timpson, Mr Edward
  362. Tomlinson, Justin
  363. Tredinnick, David
  364. Trickett, Jon
  365. Turner, Mr Andrew
  366. Turner, Karl
  367. Twigg, Derek
  368. Twigg, Stephen
  369. Tyrie, Mr Andrew
  370. Umunna, Mr Chuka
  371. Uppal, Paul
  372. Vaizey, Mr Edward
  373. Vara, Mr Shailesh
  374. Vaz, rh Keith
  375. Vickers, Martin
  376. Walker, Mr Charles
  377. Walker, Mr Robin
  378. Wallace, Mr Ben
  379. Walter, Mr Robert
  380. Ward, Mr David
  381. Watts, Mr Dave
  382. Weatherley, Mike
  383. Webb, rh Steve
  384. Wharton, James
  385. White, Chris
  386. Whitehead, Dr Alan
  387. Whittaker, Craig
  388. Whittingdale, Mr John
  389. Wiggin, Bill
  390. Willetts, rh Mr David
  391. Williams, Mr Mark
  392. Williams, Roger
  393. Williams, Stephen
  394. Williamson, Chris
  395. Williamson, Gavin
  396. Wilson, Phil
  397. Wilson, Mr Rob
  398. Wilson, Sammy
  399. Woodcock, John
  400. Woodward, rh Mr Shaun
  401. Wright, David
  402. Wright, Mr Iain
  403. Wright, rh Jeremy
  404. Wright, Simon
  405. Yeo, Mr Tim
  406. Young, rh Sir George
  407. Zahawi, Nadhim
  408. Mark Hunter
  409. Gavin Barwell

MALE MPs AGAINST AIRSTRIKES

  1. Allen, Mr Graham
  2. Bacon, Mr Richard
  3. Baron, Mr John
  4. Campbell, Mr Ronnie
  5. Caton, Martin
  6. Davidson, Mr Ian
  7. Durkan, Mark
  8. Edwards, Jonathan
  9. Flynn, Paul
  10. Galloway, George
  11. Henderson, Gordon
  12. Hepburn, Mr Stephen
  13. Holloway, Mr Adam
  14. Hopkins, Kelvin
  15. Hosie, Stewart
  16. Huppert, Dr Julian
  17. Lazarowicz, Mark
  18. MacNeil, Mr Angus Brendan
  19. McDonnell, Dr Alasdair
  20. McDonnell, John
  21. McKenzie, Mr Iain
  22. Mills, Nigel
  23. Mitchell, Austin
  24. Morris, Grahame M.
  25. Mudie, Mr George
  26. Reckless, Mark
  27. Robertson, Angus
  28. Sheerman, Mr Barry
  29. Skinner, Mr Dennis
  30. Stringer, Graham
  31. Weir, Mr Mike
  32. Williams, Hywel
  33. Wood, Mike
  34. Jeremy Corbyn
  35. Pete Wishart

8% of male MPs defied three-line whip to make an empty gesture that would only make things worse.


FEMALE MPs FOR AIRSTRIKES

  1. Abrahams, Debbie
  2. Alexander, Heidi
  3. Baldwin, Harriett
  4. Beckett, rh Margaret
  5. Berger, Luciana
  6. Blackman-Woods, Roberta
  7. Blackwood, Nicola
  8. Blears, rh Hazel
  9. Bradley, Karen
  10. Bray, Angie
  11. Brooke, rh Annette
  12. Brown, Lyn
  13. Bruce, Fiona
  14. Buck, Ms Karen
  15. Burt, Lorely
  16. Champion, Sarah
  17. Clwyd, rh Ann
  18. Coffey, Ann
  19. Coffey, Dr Thérèse
  20. Cooper, rh Yvette
  21. Creagh, Mary
  22. Creasy, Stella
  23. Crouch, Tracey
  24. De Piero, Gloria
  25. Dinenage, Caroline
  26. Dorries, Nadine
  27. Doyle, Gemma
  28. Doyle-Price, Jackie
  29. Eagle, Ms Angela
  30. Eagle, Maria
  31. Elliott, Julie
  32. Ellison, Jane
  33. Engel, Natascha
  34. Featherstone, rh Lynne
  35. Flint, rh Caroline
  36. Fovargue, Yvonne
  37. Fullbrook, Lorraine
  38. Gillan, rh Mrs Cheryl
  39. Glass, Pat
  40. Glindon, Mrs Mary
  41. Goodman, Helen
  42. Grant, Mrs Helen
  43. Green, Kate
  44. Greening, rh Justine
  45. Greenwood, Lilian
  46. Griffith, Nia
  47. Harman, rh Ms Harriet
  48. Harris, Rebecca
  49. Hillier, Meg
  50. Hilling, Julie
  51. Hillier, Meg
  52. Hodge, rh Margaret
  53. Hodgson, Mrs Sharon
  54. Jackson, Glenda
  55. James, Margot
  56. Jamieson, Cathy
  57. Jones, Susan Elan
  58. Jowell, rh Dame Tessa
  59. Kendall, Liz
  60. Latham, Pauline
  61. Leadsom, Andrea
  62. Lee, Jessica
  63. Leslie, Charlotte
  64. Lewell-Buck, Mrs Emma
  65. Long, Naomi
  66. Lumley, Karen
  67. Macleod, Mary
  68. Mahmood, Shabana
  69. Main, Mrs Anne
  70. Malhotra, Seema
  71. May, rh Mrs Theresa
  72. McCarthy, Kerry
  73. McDonagh, Siobhain
  74. McGovern, Alison
  75. McIntosh, Miss Anne
  76. McKinnell, Catherine
  77. McVey, rh Esther
  78. Miller, rh Maria
  79. Milton, Anne
  80. Moon, Mrs Madeleine
  81. Mordaunt, Penny
  82. Morden, Jessica
  83. Morgan, rh Nicky
  84. Morris, Anne Marie
  85. Munn, Meg
  86. Munt, Tessa
  87. Murray, Sheryll
  88. Nandy, Lisa
  89. Nash, Pamela
  90. Newton, Sarah
  91. Nokes, Caroline
  92. Onwurah, Chi
  93. Osborne, Sandra
  94. Patel, Priti
  95. Perry, Claire
  96. Phillipson, Bridget
  97. Powell, Lucy
  98. Reeves, Rachel
  99. Reynolds, Emma
  100. Rudd, Amber
  101. Seabeck, Alison
  102. Smith, Angela
  103. Smith, Chloe
  104. Soubry, Anna
  105. Spelman, rh Mrs Caroline
  106. Stuart, Ms Gisela
  107. Swinson, Jo
  108. Thornberry, Emily
  109. Truss, rh Elizabeth
  110. Vaz, Valerie
  111. Villiers, rh Mrs Theresa
  112. Walley, Joan
  113. Watkinson, Dame Angela
  114. Wheeler, Heather
  115. Willott, Jenny
  116. Winterton, rh Ms Rosie
  117. Wollaston, Dr Sarah

FEMALE MPs AGAINST AIRSTRIKES

  1. Abbott, Ms Diane
  2. Begg, Dame Anne
  3. Clark, Katy
  4. Hoey, Kate
  5. James, Mrs Siân C.
  6. Lucas, Caroline
  7. Riordan, Mrs Linda
  8. Ritchie, Ms Margaret
  9. Whiteford, Dr Eilidh

Only 7% of female MPs defied three-line whip to make an empty gesture that would only make things worse.


No comments: