Muslims have the Koran containing rules from God, but Christians, Liberals, Conservatives and Nationalists wouldn't be able to agree their principles, let alone compile an official handbook/book of rules for their ideology. That is why the future cannot be anything other than Islamic when the West regains its senses, and we must hope that it will be sooner rather than later.
After all, what religion would you choose that is closest to Christianity but more rule-based than the New Testament, which is not rule-based at all? It can hardly be Hinduism or Buddhism.
18 comments:
The west will never 'adopt' the Koran. It would have to be imposed by force or demographic preponderance, in which case the UK will have ceased to exist in anything but name only, anyway. I think civil war is probably the only desirable outcome. It might settle the issue for a few hundred years.
Why is civil war desirable?
Well it's preferable to becoming underlings in one's own country.
Why would white people become "underlings" in their own country under Secular Koranism?
Do you know you don't have to convert to Islam and be Muslim to adopt Secular Koranism?
Do you know the difference between a legal system and a belief system?
Are you saying you would prefer a Christian revival?
Do you envisage a Christian revival after a civil war?
Are you aware of Christian on Christian religious persecution in the burned and bloody history of Christianity?
Are you sure people would choose forced church attendance under Christianity to Secular Koranism which guarantees freedom of belief under https://Quran.com/2/256?
Are you aware that the the White House Koran is Thomas Jefferson's who bought and read it as a law student?
Are you aware that it was Jefferson who drafted the Virginia Statute that later became the First Amendment?
If you believed in God you would have to believe that everything happens for a reason. Do you see that it would be logical for God if He exists to allow three Christian global empires to rise and fall before being replaced by Islam?
Even if God didn't exist, it would still have to happen this way because Christianity has inferior scripture with inferior content written by mortal and fallible men which is no basis for the rule of law, which allows nations to prosper and empires to expand.
But it just wouldn't play out as you suggest. To put it crudely, who would be 'in charge' of the new regime, enlightened white western secularists, or ....? Do you begin to see the problem?
Anyone legally trained and who has passed an exam in Koranic Knowledge would be able to practise the law under Secular Koranism. Do you really think I am asking brown Muslims to administer the law for us?
So which internal mechanism will make the mass of people cleave to the words of The Koran, while at the same time they have no intrinsic faith in their veracity?
Do you think there are more white lawyer than brown lawyers?
The Johnson cabinet is stuffed with Asians.
So 'brown muslims' will happily go along with being by-standers of their own religion, as it's co-opted by non-believers for 'secular ends.' That should work out well ...
Nobody has to "cleave to the words of the Koran" whatever that means. They just have to take care that they don't break the law.
Such people (BJ's cabinet) would be swept aside in an 'Islamic revolution.'
It's just poppycock Claire - try to re-engage with real politics.
'Cleave to.' Stick with ... 'obey.'
Brown Muslims have always differed with each other on interpretation because there is more than one school of sharia, in case you haven't noticed.
Real politics is obsessed with Jews and Muslims.
You honestly think that matters? Of course, we'd also have Sunnis and Shias at each other's throats, just to make things even more wonderful ...
I think you are too swayed by 'life on the ground' in Malaysia. Western Europe is not Malaysia.
Christianity is still more schismatic than Islam, as you well know. Nobody but Christians has had a continent wide European War of Religions. Then they went to America and had an American Civil War.
That's all froth - not germane to the core issue of what kind of country white conservatives/nationalists want to live in.
How have I been swayed by life "on the ground" - whatever that means - in Malaysia?
You HAVEN'T been influenced by a *fairly* benign form of Islamic hegemony in your OWN country?
White people who identify as Conservatives and Nationalists have no official handbook of either Conservatism and Nationalism. Nationalists dare not even discuss the definition of nationalism. Roger Scruton, the late Conservative philosopher, lived and died without discovering what it was that Conservatives were supposed to conserve. Just admit that Christianity is a made up religion created to mock and punish Jews whose time has come and gone.
A recipe should not be judged by the results by a cook who failed to follow it.
You have already said Christianity is "not as important" to you and "no longer essential". Do you think it is possible for any society to exist without a religion?
Post a Comment