How could Moses have written the Torah if it mentions his own death?

Understanding Beliefs: An Open Space https://t.co/vNpTxf7PpH

— 🧞GenieOG🧞 (@GenieOG01) May 23, 2025

4:00  Tovia Singer

8:00  Heretical Conservative Jew

11:00  13 Principles of Judaism

53:00  CLAIRE KHAW joins.

"The beginning of wisdom is fear of the Lord." 

There are significant debates about who wrote the Torah and whether Moses was truly its author. The Torah, which consists of the first five books of the Bible (Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy), is traditionally attributed to Moses in many religious communities, particularly within Judaism and Christianity. However, several issues have led scholars to question this view, including the mention of Moses' death in the text itself. Let’s explore this in detail.

Traditional View: Moses as the Author

• Religious Tradition: According to Jewish and Christian beliefs, Moses wrote the Torah under divine inspiration. This idea is supported by passages within the Torah, such as Exodus 24:4 ("Moses wrote down all the words of the Lord") and Deuteronomy 31:9 ("Moses wrote this law and gave it to the priests"). Later religious texts, like the Talmud, also reinforce this tradition.
• Cultural Significance: For many believers, Moses’ authorship is a foundational aspect of the Torah’s authority and sacredness.

Challenges to Mosaic Authorship

However, modern biblical scholarship has raised several points that challenge the idea that Moses wrote the entire Torah. Here are the key issues:

1. The Death of Moses

• Textual Evidence: Deuteronomy 34:5-12 describes Moses’ death: "So Moses the servant of the Lord died there in the land of Moab, according to the word of the Lord." It also says, "There has not arisen a prophet since in Israel like Moses" (Deuteronomy 34:10), which implies a perspective from a later time.
• Logical Question: If Moses wrote the Torah, how could he have written about his own death in the past tense? Some traditional explanations suggest that Moses wrote this prophetically or that Joshua, his successor, added the account after Moses died. However, this has led many scholars to argue that at least this section—and possibly more—was written by someone else.

2. Anachronisms

• Historical Clues: The Torah contains references that seem out of place if it was written during Moses’ lifetime (around 1200 BCE). For example:
  • Genesis 12:6 notes, "the Canaanites were then in the land," suggesting the text was written after the Israelites had settled in Canaan, when the Canaanites were no longer the dominant group.
  • Place names, like "Dan" in Genesis 14:14, refer to locations renamed after Moses’ time.
• Implication: These anachronisms indicate that parts of the Torah were likely composed or edited long after Moses.

3. Literary and Stylistic Variations

• Multiple Voices: Scholars have observed differences in style, vocabulary, and theological focus across the Torah. This has led to the Documentary Hypothesis, which proposes that the Torah was compiled from several distinct sources:
  • J (Yahwist): Uses "Yahweh" for God, with a narrative style.
  • E (Elohist): Uses "Elohim" for God, emphasizing northern Israelite traditions.
  • P (Priestly): Focuses on rituals, genealogies, and priestly concerns.
  • D (Deuteronomist): Found mainly in Deuteronomy, with a legal and covenantal tone.
• Compilation Process: These sources are thought to have been written at different times and later combined into the Torah we know today.

4. Doublets and Contradictions

• Repeated Stories: The Torah includes multiple versions of some events, such as:
  • Two creation accounts (Genesis 1:1-2:3 and Genesis 2:4-25), with differing details.
  • The flood narrative (Genesis 6-9), which alternates between two animals of each kind and seven pairs of clean animals.
• Explanation: These variations suggest that the text integrates different traditions or authors, rather than being the work of a single writer like Moses.

Conclusion

While tradition holds that Moses wrote the Torah, the mention of his death, along with anachronisms, stylistic differences, and narrative inconsistencies, has led many scholars to conclude that the Torah was likely written by multiple authors over time. Moses may have contributed to its early content—perhaps laws or oral traditions—but the final text appears to be a later compilation. This scholarly perspective doesn’t negate the Torah’s religious importance but offers a different view of its historical origins. So, yes, there are indeed issues about who wrote the Torah, and the mention of Moses’ death is a key piece of evidence in this ongoing debate.

57:00  AHMAD JAVAD joins to anticipate the conversion of Jews to Islam.

1:01:00  MICHAEL mentions the Noahide laws.

1:43:00  AHMAD JAVAD discusses the Uncaused First Cause.

1:53:00  Idolatry

1:54:00  Hermeticism

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermeticism

1:55:00  Brother's suicide

2:05:00  Sufi and Kabbalah

2:08:00  TEKKUN on gender dysphoria. 

2:18:00  Tovia Singer

2:21:00  Jew talking to Nick Fuentes

2:25:00  Israel

2:26:00  Jew thinks Israeli was created by the Rothschilds and Jews are being tricked. 

2:28:00  Tefillin

2:35:00  Simon Jacobson

2:39:00  20% of Israelis are Arabs.

2:44:00  Ha ha CHABAD