The motte-and-bailey fallacy is an informal fallacy where an arguer conflates a controversial, hard-to-defend position (the "bailey") with a modest, easy-to-defend statement (the "motte"). Under challenge, they retreat to the safe motte, then claim victory for the bailey once the opponent withdraws.Key Components & Examples:The Bailey (Desired Position): The controversial, often unreasonable claim the speaker wants to uphold.The Motte (Defensible Position): A simplified, often trivial truth that is hard to argue against.The Shift: A speaker says, "Social media is destroying society" (Bailey), but when challenged, retreats to "Well, it's undeniable that social media has some negative effects" (Motte).Common Examples:"Crystals can cure cancer" (Bailey) shifts to "Well, feeling hopeful helps healing" (Motte) when challenged."All politicians are corrupt" (Bailey) shifts to "Well, some politicians are corrupt" (Motte).This tactic, identified by philosopher Nicholas Shackel in 2005, exploits the audience's inability to distinguish between the two distinct claims, functioning as a form of bait-and-switch.
13:00 Modern contraception has caused a greater demand for abortion on demand.
15:00 Rules are made to be broken.
16:00 "Direct negative effect"
17:00 Latent damage
18:00 The cure is worse than the disease.
19:00 Corporal punishment
20:00 Men never suffer from unwanted pregnancy.
21:00 It is incumbent on the party most at risk to take more care.
Shotgun marriage
22:00 Why the Koran?
23:00 Attaching myself to a rising religious group worshiping the most powerful being conceivable would help obtain support for my ideas than simply telling people what I think would be necessary to fix society.
The nature and purpose of religion
24:00 The belief that good will be rewarded and evil punished in this life and the next incentivises people to behave correctly.
25:00 Secular Koranism is addressed to atheists, agnostics and nihilists and an attempt to regulate their behaviour.
26:00 "There is a law against it and the punishment will fit the crime" is the ultimate deterrent.
27:00 Crime and prison statistics
30:00 Men of fighting age of all races and religions tend to get into trouble with police more than men not of fighting age.
33:00 Hypocrites who claim to be a member of a religious group
34:00 The Religion of Mum and Dad
Cultural Christians and Cultural Muslims
35:00 Shouldn't America be one nation under God trusting in God?
36:00 Only 5% of Americans are atheists?
37:00 Heretics
39:00 Iran has made the most of sharia.
40:00 Uncontrolled mass immigration
41:00 Trump, ICE and Minneapolis
Income
43:00 Comparative religion
44:00 IC codes
45:00 White Nationalism has become Christian Nationalism.
46:00 Dividing people into race
47:00 Raymond Cattell
48:00 The Domestic Partnership will replace gay marriage.
49:00 Cross-referencing race and religion for research reasons
50:00 Race distinctions
51:00 Freedom of contract
52:00 How is Secular Koranism "Nazi"?
53:00 Job application form
55:00 DEI and POTUS
56:00 DEI is the current Woke religion.
58:00 White males would benefit from Secular Koranism.
59:00 My liberal instincts
1:00:00 Criticisms of Secular Koranism
1:01:00 Polari
1:02:00 SIMOS joins to ask about lesbians holding hands and kissing in public.
1:04:00 Niqab
Iran
1:05:00 Sykes-Picot Agreement
Horror story about Iran
1:07:00 Controlling the interpretation
DECONVERTED MAN joins to denounce me.
1:09:00 Why Secular Koranism
1:10:00 Secular Koranism does not infringe against the First Amendment because it is not the government establishment of religion.
1:12:00 Vincent Bruno
1:14:00 Objective measure of mixed race people
1:16:00 Gender is a social construct.
Genomes
1:18:00 Authoritarian
1:20:00 WW3 is being started by America.
1:22:00 Secular Koranism was conceived of in 2009.
1:23:00 VINCENT BRUNO joins to discuss Beyondism.
1:27:00 How Beyondism works under Secular Koranism
1:35:00 The natural way
1:36:00 Polygamy and incest under Beyondism
1:37:00 Not a hereditarian
1:40:00 FANTOM asks about slavery on Secular Koranism
1:41:00 Opening a Slave Manumission account at the Department of Work, Pensions and Manumissions
Queens who become royal nannies and civil slaves
1:42:00 Slavery was what made America great.
1:43:00 Slavery is an institution like marriage and prostitution.
1:44:00 Homicide in its varieties
Slavery is a way of regulating labour relations.
1:45:00 Work release and workfare
1:46:00 FANTOM steelmans my proposal to reintroduce slavery.
1:47:00 Chattel slavery and indentured servitude
1:48:00 ROBIN joins to discuss public schools under Secular Koranism.
1:49:00 A, B and B+ schools
1:53:00 Equal distribution of educational resources
1:56:00 To make a point
1:57:00 A year's period of grace
2:04:00 My response to Simos's criticism
No comments:
Post a Comment