Translate

Monday, 16 November 2026

I deny the problem of evil


1:09:00  CLAIRE KHAW joins.

We have to at least agree to obey what are supposed to be the laws of God to prevent things from getting from bad to worse. 

1:10:00  We will only defend our moral principles if we have religious principles and we will only have moral and religious principles we are prepared to defend if we claim to have a religion that believes in the afterlife where good will be rewarded and evil punished. 

1:11:00  Atheists won't be able to on a definition of evil or agree on the laws they are to live under unless they refer to a Hypothetical Supreme Authority who is supposed to be perfectly moral capable of rewarding good and punishing evil in this life and the next. 

1:11:00  Daniel Leroy AKA Objective Ethics on YouTube claims to have arrived at objective morality, but no one agrees with him. 

1:12:00  Is there an ancient civilisation of atheists that still exists?

No, there was no ancient civilization that was entirely atheistic. Across the ancient world, public life, governance, law, and culture were deeply intertwined with religion, polytheism, animism, or ritual belief systems. [1, 2, 3]
However, atheistic individuals and philosophical traditions did exist in antiquity: [1, 2]
  • Ancient Greece and Rome: While society as a whole was strictly polytheistic—and open disbelief could occasionally lead to social ostracism, exile, or prosecution (such as the bounty placed on Diagoras of Melos)—skepticism and disbelief were surprisingly common among intellectuals. Scholars like Tim Whitmarsh (Battling the Gods) note that figures like Xenophanes, the Epicureans, and playwrights like Euripides actively questioned or rejected divine intervention. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
  • Ancient India: Philosophical schools such as Charvaka (or Lokayata) emerged as early as the 6th century BCE, promoting radical materialism, skepticism toward the Vedas, and the rejection of the supernatural or an afterlife. [1]
  • Ancient China: Classical philosophical traditions like Confucianism focused heavily on humanistic ethics, social order, and worldly duties rather than theology or the worship of transcendent deities, leading to a largely non-theistic cultural orientation for many scholars. [1]
Even in these cultures, irreligion was restricted to specific philosophers or philosophical schools rather than defining an entire state or civilization. [1, 2]
1:14:00  Hindus have no principles.

1:17:00  Dharma is vague shit. 

1:18:00  Karma is Cause and effect

Ahimsa

1:19:00  Honesty

1:20:00  Idolatry is evil. 

Isaiah 45:7

1:21:00  God allows even evil people the option of redemption.

Job was tested. 

1:22:00  Mortals want to go to  heaven. 

1:24:00  God will not burden a soul with more than it can bear. 

1:25:00  Sodomy is a mortal sin. 

1:26:00  Kant's Principle of Universalisability

1:27:00  Hypocrites are Hell-bound because hypocrisy is a mortal sin. 

1:28:00  A system of sticks and carrot

1:29:00  The utility of God

1:30:00  Good behaviour must encouraged by the law and bad behaviour discouraged. 

1:31:00  The law

1:32:00  Jehovah's Witnesses are annihilationists.

1:33:00  We must make the distinction between believing Jews, Christians, Muslims, Hindus and Buddhists and the hypocrites who do not believe in the afterlife. 

1:35:00  The problem of evil

1:36:00  This life is an examination hall. 

1:37:00  Karma explains the suffering of the apparently innocent. 

1:38:00  I deny the problem of evil.

Reincarnation is impossible to falsify. Ditto the existence or non-existence of God. 

1:39:00  There is no ancient civilisation of atheists. 

1:40:00  The total of people who are supposed to believe in the afterlife in the world is nearly 6 billion. 

1:41:00  Charity is encouraged by all five world religions. 

1:42:00  Koranic principles of governance would have the effect of improving government. 

1:43:00  Even atheists want the rule of  law. 

1:44:00  There will always be people who break the law but people who trust in the source of the law are less likely to break it. 

1:48:00  Isaiah 45:7

1:50:00  We want eternal life because most of us are afraid to die. God already has it, being immortal.

1:51:00  God never promised us a rose garden. 

Because evil exists, God doesn't?

1:52:00  God if He exists rewards good and punishes evil in this life and the next.

No comments:

I deny the problem of evil

1:09:00  CLAIRE KHAW joins. We have to at least agree to obey what are supposed to be the laws of God to prevent things from getting from ba...