Emasculated male MPs only very slightly more likely to defy three-line whip than female MPs

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2770534/Parliament-debates-British-military-action-Iraq.html

MALE MPs FOR AIRSTRIKES

1. Adams, Nigel
2. Afriyie, Adam
3. Ainsworth, rh Mr Bob
4. Aldous, Peter
5. Alexander, rh Danny
6. Alexander, rh Mr Douglas
7. Amess, Mr David
8. Anderson, Mr David
9. Andrew, Stuart
10. Arbuthnot, rh Mr James
11. Ashworth, Jonathan
12. Austin, Ian
13. Bailey, Mr Adrian
14. Bain, Mr William
15. Baldry, rh Sir Tony
16. Balls, rh Ed
17. Banks, Gordon
18. Barclay, Stephen
19. Barker, rh Gregory
20. Barron, rh Kevin
21. Bayley, Hugh
22. Bebb, Guto
23. Beith, rh Sir Alan
24. Bellingham, Mr Henry
25. Benn, rh Hilary
26. Benyon, Richard
27. Beresford, Sir Paul
28. Berry, Jake
29. Betts, Mr Clive
30. Bingham, Andrew
31. Binley, Mr Brian
32. Blackman, Bob
33. Blenkinsop, Tom
34. Blomfield, Paul
35. Blunkett, rh Mr David
36. Boles, Nick
37. Bone, Mr Peter
38. Brady, Mr Graham
39. Brake, rh Tom
40. Brazier, Mr Julian
41. Brennan, Kevin
42. Bridgen, Andrew
43. Brine, Steve
44. Brokenshire, James
45. Brown, rh Mr Nicholas
46. Brown, Mr Russell
47. Browne, Mr Jeremy
48. Bruce, rh Sir Malcolm
49. Buckland, Mr Robert
50. Burden, Richard
51. Burley, Mr Aidan
52. Burnham, rh Andy
53. Burns, Conor
54. Burrowes, Mr David
55. Burstow, rh Paul
56. Burt, rh Alistair
57. Byles, Dan
58. Byrne, rh Mr Liam
59. Cable, rh Vince
60. Cairns, Alun
61. Cameron, rh Mr David
62. Campbell, rh Mr Alan
63. Campbell, Mr Gregory
64. Campbell, rh Sir Menzies
65. Carmichael, rh Mr Alistair
66. Carmichael, Neil
67. Cash, Sir William
68. Chishti, Rehman
69. Chope, Mr Christopher
70. Clappison, Mr James
71. Clark, rh Greg
72. Clarke, rh Mr Kenneth
73. Clarke, rh Mr Tom
74. Clegg, rh Mr Nick
75. Clifton-Brown, Geoffrey
76. Coaker, Vernon
77. Collins, Damian
78. Colvile, Oliver
79. Cox, Mr Geoffrey
80. Crabb, rh Stephen
81. Crausby, Mr David
82. Crockart, Mike
83. Cruddas, Jon
84. Cryer, John
85. Cunningham, Alex
86. Cunningham, Mr Jim
87. Cunningham, Sir Tony
88. Danczuk, Simon
89. Darling, rh Mr Alistair
90. Davey, rh Mr Edward
91. David, Wayne
92. Davies, David T. C.
93. Davies, Geraint
94. Davies, Glyn
95. de Bois, Nick
96. Denham, rh Mr John
97. Djanogly, Mr Jonathan
98. Dobson, rh Frank
99. Docherty, Thomas
100. Dodds, rh Mr Nigel
101. Donaldson, rh Mr Jeffrey M.
102. Doughty, Stephen
103. Dowd, Jim
104. Drax, Richard
105. Dromey, Jack
106. Duddridge, James
107. Dugher, Michael
108. Duncan, rh Sir Alan
109. Duncan Smith, rh Mr Iain
110. Dunne, Mr Philip
111. Efford, Clive
112. Ellis, Michael
113. Ellwood, Mr Tobias
114. Elphicke, Charlie
115. Esterson, Bill
116. Eustice, George
117. Evans, Chris
118. Evans, Graham
119. Evans, Jonathan
120. Evans, Mr Nigel
121. Evennett, Mr David
122. Fallon, rh Michael
123. Farrelly, Paul
124. Farron, Tim
125. Field, rh Mr Frank
126. Field, Mark
127. Flello, Robert
128. Foster, rh Mr Don
129. Fox, rh Dr Liam
130. Francis, Dr Hywel
131. Francois, rh Mr Mark
132. Freeman, George
133. Freer, Mike
134. Fuller, Richard
135. Gapes, Mike
136. Gardiner, Barry
137. Garnier, Sir Edward
138. Garnier, Mark
139. Gauke, Mr David
140. George, Andrew
141. Gibb, Mr Nick
142. Gilbert, Stephen
143. Glen, John
144. Goldsmith, Zac
145. Goodwill, Mr Robert
146. Gove, rh Michael
147. Graham, Richard
148. Gray, Mr James
149. Grayling, rh Chris
150. Greatrex, Tom
151. Green, rh Damian
152. Grieve, rh Mr Dominic
153. Griffiths, Andrew
154. Gummer, Ben
155. Gwynne, Andrew
156. Gyimah, Mr Sam
157. Hague, rh Mr William
158. Hain, rh Mr Peter
159. Halfon, Robert
160. Hames, Duncan
161. Hamilton, Fabian
162. Hammond, rh Mr Philip
163. Hammond, Stephen
164. Hancock, rh Matthew
165. Hancock, Mr Mike
166. Hands, rh Greg
167. Harper, Mr Mark
168. Harrington, Richard
169. Harris, Mr Tom
170. Harvey, Sir Nick
171. Haselhurst, rh Sir Alan
172. Havard, Mr Dai
173. Hayes, rh Mr John
174. Heald, Sir Oliver
175. Healey, rh John
176. Heaton-Harris, Chris
177. Hemming, John
178. Hendrick, Mark
179. Hendry, Charles
180. Herbert, rh Nick
181. Heyes, David
182. Hinds, Damian
183. Hoban, Mr Mark
184. Hollingbery, George
185. Hollobone, Mr Philip
186. Hood, Mr Jim
187. Hopkins, Kris
188. Horwood, Martin
189. Howarth, rh Mr George
190. Howarth, Sir Gerald
191. Howell, John
192. Hughes, rh Simon
193. Hunt, rh Mr Jeremy
194. Hunt, Tristram
195. Hurd, Mr Nick
196. Irranca-Davies, Huw
197. Jackson, Mr Stewart
198. Jarvis, Dan
199. Javid, rh Sajid
200. Jenkin, Mr Bernard
201. Jenrick, Robert
202. Johnson, Gareth
203. Johnson, Joseph
204. Jones, Andrew
205. Jones, rh Mr David
206. Jones, Graham
207. Jones, Mr Kevan
208. Jones, Mr Marcus
209. Joyce, Eric
210. Kane, Mike
211. Kawczynski, Daniel
212. Kelly, Chris
213. Khan, rh Sadiq
214. Kirby, Simon
215. Knight, rh Sir Greg
216. Kwarteng, Kwasi
217. Lamb, rh Norman
218. Lammy, rh Mr David
219. Lancaster, Mark
220. Lansley, rh Mr Andrew
221. Laws, rh Mr David
222. Lee, Dr Phillip
223. Lefroy, Jeremy
224. Leigh, Sir Edward
225. Leslie, Chris
226. Letwin, rh Mr Oliver
227. Lewis, Brandon
228. Lewis, Mr Ivan
229. Lewis, Dr Julian
230. Lidington, rh Mr David
231. Lilley, rh Mr Peter
232. Lloyd, Stephen
233. Lopresti, Jack
234. Lord, Jonathan
235. Loughton, Tim
236. Love, Mr Andrew
237. Lucas, Ian
238. Luff, Sir Peter
239. Mahmood, Mr Khalid
240. Mann, John
241. Marsden, Mr Gordon
242. Maude, rh Mr Francis
243. Maynard, Paul
244. McCabe, Steve
245. McCann, Mr Michael
246. McCartney, Jason
247. McCartney, Karl
248. McCrea, Dr William
249. McDonald, Andy
250. McFadden, rh Mr Pat
251. McGovern, Jim
252. McLoughlin, rh Mr Patrick
253. Meacher, rh Mr Michael
254. Meale, Sir Alan
255. Mearns, Ian
256. Menzies, Mark
257. Metcalfe, Stephen
258. Miliband, rh Edward
259. Miller, Andrew
260. Mitchell, rh Mr Andrew
261. Moore, rh Michael
262. Morris, David
263. Morris, James
264. Mosley, Stephen
265. Mowat, David
266. Mulholland, Greg
267. Mundell, rh David
268. Murphy, rh Mr Jim
269. Murphy, rh Paul
270. Murrison, Dr Andrew
271. Neill, Robert
272. Newmark, Mr Brooks
273. Nuttall, Mr David
274. O'Brien, rh Mr Stephen
275. Offord, Dr Matthew
276. Ollerenshaw, Eric
277. Opperman, Guy
278. Osborne, rh Mr George
279. Ottaway, rh Sir Richard
280. Owen, Albert
281. Paice, rh Sir James
282. Paisley, Ian
283. Parish, Neil
284. Paterson, rh Mr Owen
285. Pawsey, Mark
286. Penning, rh Mike
287. Penrose, John
288. Percy, Andrew
289. Perkins, Toby
290. Phillips, Stephen
291. Pickles, rh Mr Eric
292. Pincher, Christopher
293. Poulter, Dr Daniel
294. Pound, Stephen
295. Pritchard, Mark
296. Pugh, John
297. Raab, Mr Dominic
298. Randall, rh Sir John
299. Raynsford, rh Mr Nick
300. Reed, Mr Jamie
301. Reed, Mr Steve
302. Rees-Mogg, Jacob
303. Reevell, Simon
304. Reid, Mr Alan
305. Reynolds, Jonathan
306. Robathan, rh Mr Andrew
307. Robertson, rh Sir Hugh
308. Robertson, John
309. Robertson, Mr Laurence
310. Robinson, Mr Geoffrey
311. Rogerson, Dan
312. Rosindell, Andrew
313. Roy, Lindsay
314. Ruane, Chris
315. Russell, Sir Bob
316. Rutley, David
317. Sanders, Mr Adrian
318. Sarwar, Anas
319. Sawford, Andy
320. Selous, Andrew
321. Shannon, Jim
322. Shapps, rh Grant
323. Sharma, Alok
324. Sharma, Mr Virendra
325. Shepherd, Sir Richard
326. Sheridan, Jim
327. Shuker, Gavin
328. Simmonds, Mark
329. Simpson, David
330. Simpson, Mr Keith
331. Skidmore, Chris
332. Slaughter, Mr Andy
333. Smith, Henry
334. Smith, Julian
335. Smith, Nick
336. Smith, Owen
337. Smith, Sir Robert
338. Soames, rh Sir Nicholas
339. Spellar, rh Mr John
340. Spencer, Mr Mark
341. Stanley, rh Sir John
342. Stephenson, Andrew
343. Stevenson, John
344. Stewart, Bob
345. Stewart, Iain
346. Stewart, Rory
347. Streeter, Mr Gary
348. Stride, Mel
349. Stuart, Mr Graham
350. Stunell, rh Sir Andrew
351. Sturdy, Julian
352. Sutcliffe, Mr Gerry
353. Swales, Ian
354. Swayne, rh Mr Desmond
355. Swire, rh Mr Hugo
356. Syms, Mr Robert
357. Tami, Mark
358. Thomas, Mr Gareth
359. Thornton, Mike
360. Timms, rh Stephen
361. Timpson, Mr Edward
362. Tomlinson, Justin
363. Tredinnick, David
364. Trickett, Jon
365. Turner, Mr Andrew
366. Turner, Karl
367. Twigg, Derek
368. Twigg, Stephen
369. Tyrie, Mr Andrew
370. Umunna, Mr Chuka
371. Uppal, Paul
372. Vaizey, Mr Edward
373. Vara, Mr Shailesh
374. Vaz, rh Keith
375. Vickers, Martin
376. Walker, Mr Charles
377. Walker, Mr Robin
378. Wallace, Mr Ben
379. Walter, Mr Robert
380. Ward, Mr David
381. Watts, Mr Dave
382. Weatherley, Mike
383. Webb, rh Steve
384. Wharton, James
385. White, Chris
386. Whitehead, Dr Alan
387. Whittaker, Craig
388. Whittingdale, Mr John
389. Wiggin, Bill
390. Willetts, rh Mr David
391. Williams, Mr Mark
392. Williams, Roger
393. Williams, Stephen
394. Williamson, Chris
395. Williamson, Gavin
396. Wilson, Phil
397. Wilson, Mr Rob
398. Wilson, Sammy
399. Woodcock, John
400. Woodward, rh Mr Shaun
401. Wright, David
402. Wright, Mr Iain
403. Wright, rh Jeremy
404. Wright, Simon
405. Yeo, Mr Tim
406. Young, rh Sir George
407. Zahawi, Nadhim
408. Mark Hunter
409. Gavin Barwell

MALE MPs AGAINST AIRSTRIKES

1. Allen, Mr Graham
2. Bacon, Mr Richard
3. Baron, Mr John
4. Campbell, Mr Ronnie
5. Caton, Martin
6. Davidson, Mr Ian
7. Durkan, Mark
8. Edwards, Jonathan
9. Flynn, Paul
10. Galloway, George
11. Henderson, Gordon
12. Hepburn, Mr Stephen
13. Holloway, Mr Adam
14. Hopkins, Kelvin
15. Hosie, Stewart
16. Huppert, Dr Julian
17. Lazarowicz, Mark
18. MacNeil, Mr Angus Brendan
19. McDonnell, Dr Alasdair
20. McDonnell, John
21. McKenzie, Mr Iain
22. Mills, Nigel
23. Mitchell, Austin
24. Morris, Grahame M.
25. Mudie, Mr George
26. Reckless, Mark
27. Robertson, Angus
28. Sheerman, Mr Barry
29. Skinner, Mr Dennis
30. Stringer, Graham
31. Weir, Mr Mike
32. Williams, Hywel
33. Wood, Mike
34. Jeremy Corbyn
35. Pete Wishart

8% of male MPs defied three-line whip to make an empty gesture that would only make things worse.

FEMALE MPs FOR AIRSTRIKES

1. Abrahams, Debbie
2. Alexander, Heidi
3. Baldwin, Harriett
4. Beckett, rh Margaret
5. Berger, Luciana
6. Blackman-Woods, Roberta
7. Blackwood, Nicola
8. Blears, rh Hazel
9. Bradley, Karen
10. Bray, Angie
11. Brooke, rh Annette
12. Brown, Lyn
13. Bruce, Fiona
14. Buck, Ms Karen
15. Burt, Lorely
16. Champion, Sarah
17. Clwyd, rh Ann
18. Coffey, Ann
19. Coffey, Dr Thérèse
20. Cooper, rh Yvette
21. Creagh, Mary
22. Creasy, Stella
23. Crouch, Tracey
24. De Piero, Gloria
25. Dinenage, Caroline
26. Dorries, Nadine
27. Doyle, Gemma
28. Doyle-Price, Jackie
29. Eagle, Ms Angela
30. Eagle, Maria
31. Elliott, Julie
32. Ellison, Jane
33. Engel, Natascha
34. Featherstone, rh Lynne
35. Flint, rh Caroline
36. Fovargue, Yvonne
37. Fullbrook, Lorraine
38. Gillan, rh Mrs Cheryl
39. Glass, Pat
40. Glindon, Mrs Mary
41. Goodman, Helen
42. Grant, Mrs Helen
43. Green, Kate
44. Greening, rh Justine
45. Greenwood, Lilian
46. Griffith, Nia
47. Harman, rh Ms Harriet
48. Harris, Rebecca
49. Hillier, Meg
50. Hilling, Julie
51. Hillier, Meg
52. Hodge, rh Margaret
53. Hodgson, Mrs Sharon
54. Jackson, Glenda
55. James, Margot
56. Jamieson, Cathy
57. Jones, Susan Elan
58. Jowell, rh Dame Tessa
59. Kendall, Liz
60. Latham, Pauline
61. Leadsom, Andrea
62. Lee, Jessica
63. Leslie, Charlotte
64. Lewell-Buck, Mrs Emma
65. Long, Naomi
66. Lumley, Karen
67. Macleod, Mary
68. Mahmood, Shabana
69. Main, Mrs Anne
70. Malhotra, Seema
71. May, rh Mrs Theresa
72. McCarthy, Kerry
73. McDonagh, Siobhain
74. McGovern, Alison
75. McIntosh, Miss Anne
76. McKinnell, Catherine
77. McVey, rh Esther
78. Miller, rh Maria
79. Milton, Anne
80. Moon, Mrs Madeleine
81. Mordaunt, Penny
82. Morden, Jessica
83. Morgan, rh Nicky
84. Morris, Anne Marie
85. Munn, Meg
86. Munt, Tessa
87. Murray, Sheryll
88. Nandy, Lisa
89. Nash, Pamela
90. Newton, Sarah
91. Nokes, Caroline
92. Onwurah, Chi
93. Osborne, Sandra
94. Patel, Priti
95. Perry, Claire
96. Phillipson, Bridget
97. Powell, Lucy
98. Reeves, Rachel
99. Reynolds, Emma
100. Rudd, Amber
101. Seabeck, Alison
102. Smith, Angela
103. Smith, Chloe
104. Soubry, Anna
105. Spelman, rh Mrs Caroline
106. Stuart, Ms Gisela
107. Swinson, Jo
108. Thornberry, Emily
109. Truss, rh Elizabeth
110. Vaz, Valerie
111. Villiers, rh Mrs Theresa
112. Walley, Joan
113. Watkinson, Dame Angela
114. Wheeler, Heather
115. Willott, Jenny
116. Winterton, rh Ms Rosie
117. Wollaston, Dr Sarah

FEMALE MPs AGAINST AIRSTRIKES

1. Abbott, Ms Diane
2. Begg, Dame Anne
3. Clark, Katy
4. Hoey, Kate
5. James, Mrs Siân C.
6. Lucas, Caroline
7. Riordan, Mrs Linda
8. Ritchie, Ms Margaret
9. Whiteford, Dr Eilidh

Only 7% of female MPs defied three-line whip to make an empty gesture that would only make things worse.

The West’s sad semi-war against ISIS is worse than useless

INTERVENTION IS MAKING THINGS WORSE – AGAIN

ISIS: a monster made by the moralists of the West